Best polyester vs nylon sling climbing reddit. The discussion over nylon vs.

Best polyester vs nylon sling climbing reddit Sep 1, 2023 · In the battle between nylon and Dyneema for the best material for climbing slings, it might seem that nylon is slowly losing the battle. Strap works has best selection IMHO but if you can find tubular nylon it is best choice for me. Been a long time since I used 60 cm nylon slings for the last time. not to discourage you from asking stuff but just in general 1x 120cm nylon runner tied into what I call a "baby quad". Nylon also keeps its strength up to 20% of stretch from what I’m reading. The tubular polyester webbings from slack. Jan 14, 2019 · Both nylon and polyester slings are good for delicate loads, but if you're wondering which one is best for the most delicate loads, it's polyester. Although the Techweb slings have loosened up some with use, just not a greatly. Dyneema. GameStop Moderna Pfizer Johnson & Johnson AstraZeneca Walgreens Best Buy Novavax SpaceX Tesla. I also really like having a few burly nylon slings mixed in. Let's think about the facts for a moment: Chemical damage of nylon rope usually also causes discolouration. The discussion over nylon vs. The European market is the exact opposite—they have historically used upward of 90% polyester webbing for slings. Long enough to build and anchor and tie a knot in so you can clip two bolts when using as a PAS. Standing around for 10min trying to untie a frozen, weighted dyneema sling is bad style. Elasticity: Nylon has some elasticity, which can help maintain tension in straps. If it's non-reactive with condoms, I doubt it's going to be an issue for nylon. While polyester doesn't seem to sag, but the trade off is weight and strength. It is IMHO the best choice for hammock camping use once all variables are assessed - #1 reason being little to no stretch. Oct 6, 2009 · Paul Reineck wrote:Not sure if this is a dumb question or if it has been covered. I still use the odd 120 cm nylon slings here and there, as it's a little bit dynamic and it's easier to untie knots. Contact the manufacturer for the best answer. Astroglide is a condom safe lubricant. g. UV Resistance: Polyester is highly resistant to UV rays, so it won't degrade or weaken in prolonged sunlight exposure. Using nylon webbing or sewn slings does offer a bit of savings compared to dynex or spectra, but the bulk kills that for me. Its that the DMM video was in specific circumstances with dynamic falls onto the slings with no rope in the system, which IS dangerous. - Really bulky with knots. While we are not suppose to fall directly on Dyneema slings and these test are worst case, it seems like nylon is the better material, but people like Dyneema because it's l Just adding another datapoint into the mix, there's the Outlier Slim Dungarees which are a combo of nylon and polyester --they are 82% nylon,16% polyester, and 2% elastane. No knots! Polyester: + Cheap. - heavy. What is the strength of tied tubular nylon? Your knot will fail before the nylon does, assuming the nylon is in good condition. If you make your own slings, tie your nylon webbing with a water knot that has long tails (at least 2" long). The melting temperature doesn't really matter either - I don't think there's been a single documented case of melted slings in alpine draws during proper use. In terms of racking it's really not that much different from having a PAS and a sling (or two slings) as personal anchors. the rope should always be taking the brunt of the force out of a fall, slings just transfer the force. Workout clothes should be polyester. That's all been replaced by dynema slings. + Fairly durable (due to quantity) + Slightly dynamic, so more margin for error (but you shouldn't be doing things where you need the dynamic part) - bulky. For situations that will put a lot of abuse on gear, like top rope anchors or multi-pitch anchors, I like cordelette or tied nylon runners. But when looking for this item, I found Cordelette specific, and also Accessory Cord. The reality is, most of us use it on our draws, most of us use it in situations where falls aren't very common, and when dynema/dynex fails it's almost always when people girth two pieces of soft gear together, not from a crazy fall onto a sling. Also most nylon shirts are blends and many polyester shirts are pure polyester. Was gonna use 2 slings to maintain contact as I climb, sort of leap frogging them, idk what thats called. View community ranking In the Top 5% of largest communities on Reddit Dyneema vs Nylon To me it seems the better choice would be nylon because of it’s stretch capabilities compared to polyester. I've tried out some of the newer slings mentioned and they're great, too. That article also add that polyester is getting cheaper and nylon is getting Knots in nylon= ok knots in dyneema= less ok but still okay. The Cordelette was smaller in diameter than the accessory cord by 1mm, yet it was advertised to have a greater load rating than pre-cut accessory cord by about 300-400 lbs Why do you want a PAS as opposed to just a couple nylon slings, girth hitched to your harness? You don't need to buy a sewn prussik loop, you can tie a prussik loop for yourself with 80 cents of 6mm nylon cord. You can also use them on natural features like trees, threads, and chickenheads. Polyester is opposite, it absorbs oils within the thread and results in those clothes that smell good out of the washer but as soon as it warms up with body temperatures the smell comes right back. Jun 15, 2020 · Bottom Line: Nylon slings could be made as skinny, safer dynamically and less expensive than Dyneema. Polyester Webbing: Strength: Like nylon, polyester webbing is strong and durable, with excellent tensile strength. A 20’ loop of cord can get you out of nearly any problem you get yourself into. 1x 240cm nylon runner that is rarely used, only for the biggest trees (and often as a basket hitch) or when the three pieces are in wildly different spots. I use 6mm nylon cord. I say nylon because it has some elasticity if you accidentally shock load it. See full list on outdoorgearlab. rated strength is NOT even close to a direct measure of safety, since an anchor is a system and no single component should ever be subjected to the breaking strength of a cord. They allow two different options for extension, ~20cm or 60cm. And that force of failure depends upon how well the knot is tied. This makes them the best choice for situations such as extending a belay device , replacing anchor webbing or attaching yourself to an anchor before abseiling . If you fall on a nylon sling with any slack, it's going to hurt. The slings were like 6” in diameter and like 20’ long. The weight rarely makes a difference to me, in any bag I'd already consider worth buying. When goretex was ungodly expensive, I typically opted for coated nylon which also tended to last longer. This DMM testing in the link below shows failure of Dyeema in fall factor 1 & 2 and nylon performed better. Material properties. If you want to rig 20m+ lines in the park, stay away from nylon. is workable and it comes down to personal preference and maybe a few minor design innovations around adjustment, materials, etc. rock horns for protection, or to connect you to an anchor. Cord is useful for creating custom-length slings, such as a cordelette, that can be used in anchor construction or in friction hitches for rappels and aid Posted by u/SettingIntentions - 1 vote and 15 comments Aug 31, 2020 · Sterling Nylon Sling; Mammut Contact Sling; Trango Low Bulk Sling; Metolius Monster Open Sling; Metolius 18mm Open Nylon Sling; Black Diamond Dynex Runner; Black Diamond Nylon Runner; Petzl ANNEAU Polyester Sling; How to Choose the Best Climbing Slings for Your Needs Nylon vs. I carry about the same number of slings in the gunks though I only carry one 120 and I supplement 2 sport QDs for 2 runners. in practice this increases overall breaking strength by about 1. I had a light coated nylon anorak I wore climbing, backpacking in the winds, bike touring in New Zealand, canoeing in the NW territories and more. A benefit of slings is that they're cheaper than the PAS and they aren't single-purpose, like a PAS is. Most any quick adjust/two-point sling from this list, or VTAC, Magpul etc. Lightweight and perfect for working out or travel, but very very expensive. It is nice to have a fatter sling for 2-screw anchors (usually a nylon-dyneema blend so it's not too fat) because it's easier to untie when you are moving on from a multipitch belay. However, people report developing a light tan under popular Echo/Capilene Cool sun shirts in the same conditions, which may also be protective. I think there's a clear reason nylon is chosen for slings on cams after reading the article. ETA: I’m not concerned about climbing weight as much as overall pack weight for multi-day excursions. Nylon has a greater tensile strength than polyester, making it particularly suitable for heavy lifting operations. Cheap, light, strong, and versatile. Shop for Bulk Webbing. Sport anchor: 2 quickdraws Trad anchor: cordelette or climbing rope hey puppup try to bounce around the internet a bit since a lot of others have been in your shoes. 1. Crypto Nov 16, 2024 · Polyester and nylon both have their applications in rigging manufacturing, but there are significant differences between the two. Here’s a detailed comparison of the two materials: 1. 3M subscribers in the climbing community. I feel like once I started climbing harder stuff it was really nice to have a few random QD's for pins or for slightly lower first pieces. When wet, it won’t breathe at all. I've never seen anyone use a sling, so I'm prejudiced against it. In a basket hitch, the rated working load was like 1. Just totally absurd and your video reminded me of those I would consider it completely wrong to say you should never use nylon, but I wouldn't start out planning on using a sling. However, polyester does wick sweat really well. If you have other suggestions I am open It sounds like you're trying to via ferrata. If it's anything like the techweb slings I have, I think I'd find it far too thick and stiff for the usage of a sling of an alpine draw. . I swear this is the first thing that anyone told me when I started climbing. rated strength is not the same concept as durability in an anchor, the most important aspect is not a single component's rated strength. perhaps the mountain project search bar and also general articles on climbing. In addition to these two main types, there are other considerations when choosing webbing: Material: Webbing can be made from various materials such as nylon, polyester, polypropylene, and aramid fibers. In a girth hitch they were like 300,000ish pounds. Personally, I think the whole static vs. Most common applications are alpine draws, slinging e. e. the accessory cord is not climbing specific so it's rated for single line loads and lists the breaking It's also commonly used in sling configurations for climbing protection. a basic knot will reduce the strength of the rope by ~50% as a general guideline. Innovative asymmetric sling constructed in durable 16 mm polyamide, with innovative loop (registered design) for connecting to harness and two arms of different lengths to facilitate rope manoeuvres. Unless you really fuck something up any stretch in the anchor should be negligible compared to the stretch in the rope (i. Arc'teryx: These were also discontinued but were my first $$$ purchase. Polyester shirts for the most part are little saunas. Nylon: Nylon fibers absorb moisture more readily than polyester, which can make nylon fabrics feel damp or clammy in humid conditions. 5x the single line rated load. The choice of material depends on factors like strength, durability Moved Permanently. Nylon is the stronger material that can make a pretty tough tent at 15D, but the trade off is that it absorbs water and sags. I'm looking at a 10mm thick 60/100cm long sling. Nylon wicking water out instead of trapping it within the polyester shirt makes it cooler. Nylon slings are a bit heavier, but having to rack 10 of those would be a massive pain. I also like using cord or nylon slings to build anchors. For an all-around sling, go with 120cm nylon. Business, Economics, and Finance. These uses tend to not be very rough on slings. And perfect an anchor setup that minimizes or eliminates knots in slings. I strongly recommend some type of energy absorbing device instead of just a nylon sling. Polyacryl, polyamide, elastan, polyester, acryl, nylon, the list goes on. Feb 28, 2023 · Two standard options are nylon and polyester slings, each boasting distinct qualities. How many slings with a single biner do y’all carry vs alpine draws? I’m tempted to cut down to 6 alpines to save a few oz on biners, as I don’t foresee placing more than 6 nuts per pitch, but I’m kind of nervous about not having enough. com and rockclimbing. if it is, you did something else very wrong. The document has moved here. Polyester is also a bit more flexible than nylon. as u/aplusbi has suggested, some of this stuff is compiled in john long's anchors and in freedom of the hills. However, nylon has a few notable advantages. A sewn kevlar sheath is the best option, but a tied 5-6mm nylon prusik loop is fine. Since I had the scale out I decided to weigh my sport draws. The home of Climbing on reddit. The ease of adjustment is really the best part, unlike the Metolius PAS you don't have to unclip anything to shorten or extend your distance to your anchor which is great. Dyneema has a lower melting point than nylon, so the heat caused by the friction of the prusik and the rope rubbing together is more likely to melt/weaken/break a dyneema third hand than a nylon third hand. Goretex breaths some but not that well. And yes we are scared of falling. The chemical coating on nylon webbing gives it a slightly more coarse texture. In nylon slings, the diameter of the nylon fibres inside the sling is tiny, so you can get away with much sharper bends, like shackle pins etc. 6 million pounds. They used their “Phasic” fabric and I found the odor and temperature control to be better than most polyester blends. Also generation less force on you if an anchor were to blow. Sep 18, 2024 · Both polyester and nylon slings offer considerable strength, but nylon slings typically have a higher load-bearing capacity. Simple solution: don't buy dyneema slings. fr are some of the best feeling for rodeolining. dynamic is a moot point considering you should never take a direct fall on either spectra or nylon slings. If the bolts are connected with a chain (thus, redundant), I clip to the chain. 2. Molecular structure: Synthesized from long polyester chains, the molecular chain is shorter and contains many ester bonds. Of course 1 person(the second) is going to need a sling and a binder to clip the master point or the shelf. The slings they had were these specialty endless slings made of Kevlar in some fancy higher denier nylon. I carry that stuff with me everywhere. ) The D:d ratio comments above are valid, but are usually spoken about in terms of wire rope. For example, I was shopping for winter socks today and saw that some are made up of as much as 4-5 different fabrics other than cotton/wool (40% polyacryl, 40% wool, 18% polyamide, 2% elastan), yet I have no idea whether that's good or bad. I do occasionally like X-Pac but mostly for slings and other light-duty bags. Depending on your risk tolerance, I would say to replace dynemma slings within 5 years and check the date of manufacturing when you're purchasing. the single strand now has to take half the shared load. #3 Durability It is expensive. Personally I think the stretch in Nylon is a bit of a red herring. You could get technical and say that it isn’t true breathability. That also will affect things. Feb 11, 2016 · Historically in the sling industry, the US market has been 80 to 90 percent nylon, using polyester where it was essential for UV or chemical resistance. So what exactly is the difference between the two? We’ll explore and compare the properties and features here so you can decide which sling fits your needs best. com Discover the key differences between nylon and polyester lifting slings to choose the best one for your lifting project. 1x 120cm nylon runner, often used for a clove v configuration or girthing a medium tree when I'm not worried about redundancy. A nylon sling would be more robust than a dyneema sling, but they are bigger and more unwieldy for such a purpose. It'll never be like a Black Diamond nylon sling in it's flexibility. #2. I'm also assuming you're talking about polyester round slings, rather than climbing slings? Bulk webbing is only available in nylon. Climbing Cord. Polyester fiber. 500d Cordura is the best of basically all worlds for a backpack IMO, but 1000d is more common and I still like it a lot. Hands down one of the best pairs I bought. Its not that strength of knotted spectra was the problem, you should pretty much assume a 50% loss in strength in any sling you tie a knot in, whether nylon or spectra. They tend to be more versatile and durable than dyneema slings, and they are cheap enough to cut up or leave behind. Usually around 16-20mm wide, nylon climbing slings are much bulkier (and more durable) than lightweight 6-14mm Dyneema slings. However, nylon's ability to absorb moisture can also make it suitable for applications where moisture transport and breathability are desired, such as in socks or base layers. I personally think mixed slings offer the best compromise. Since you're asking about trad climbing, at some point in your career you're going to have to untie and thread your sling or use it for rap tat. The most obvious is the fact that it is far more affordable than Dyneema, which is one of many reasons why the Black Diamond Nylon Sewn Runner is an ideal choice I included a sewn nylon and hand tied draw as I have seen both in the wild. cipE Use a water knot and leave 3" tails. com would be useful to read. dyneema slings is a long one Draws made from slings and biners (aka alpine draws) are nice for trad climbing when you're climbing multiple pitches below your limit. I just wanted to call attention to the McLean sling. I think you would be very happy it, and there are two color choices. Pro tip; use a adjustable sling for winter. doubling the loop doubles the strength of the system. no need for a purcell or PAS just girth hitch a sling from your tie in point and clip into the anchor, keep the sling weighted so you can't fall on it. You'll need about 10 feet of webbing to make a 4 foot sling. It seems as though the only two material choices are nylon or polyester which both come with their trade off's. You can use them for a primitive too, of course. the nylon vs dynema thing isn't anything new. If a fall were to occur the stretch on nylon might save an anchor versus polyester. No water absorbed = no issues with wet gear after rain due to seapeage or wicking type behavior. TLDR: Go for it if you are fine with clumsy gear, there is no general rule on the strength of tied tubular nylon other than it works fine. With this combo they have a 2-way stretch but due to how the fabric is woven, they are very breathable -to the point that, without long underwear, you will feel the wind up (Note on Nylon vs Polyester for sun protection: Nylon has higher UPF ratings, and might be better in deserts, alpine deserts, and sunny mountains where the air is clear, dry, and sun can be vicious. botskotma tfw fvjon jmplgx dtwkfi ikl wopdhc cdyn aazy qlikm